A P McCoy or Richard Johnson - who is better?

A P McCoy or Richard Johnson - who is better?

A simple answer - AP McCoy.

Knighted in 2016, McCoy is generally accepted as the finest rider the sport has ever produced, as a result of producing a record 4,358 winners in his time. He was also Champion Jockey a record 20 consecutive times, every year in fact he was a professional rider.

The Northern Irishman recorded his first winner back in 1992 at age of 17, claiming his first Champion Jockey title three years later.

McCoy won almost every major race there is to win, with his most high-profile winners being in the Cheltenham Gold Cup, Champion Hurdle, Champion Chase, King George VI Chase, and the 2010 Grand National aboard Don't Push It.

He was named BBC Sports Personality of the Year in 2010, becoming the first jockey to win the award, and in December 2013 he was named RTE Sports Person of the Year.

A simple answer, but perhaps not a simple explanation.

Continued..

McCoy held an intense rivalry with Richard Johnson for the Jockeys Title for many years.

In fact, Dicky Johnson was runner-up in the Jockeys’ Championship as many as 16 times behind McCoy, before finally winning it for the first time the year after McCoy retired.

Now a three-time winner of the top accolade in Jumps' Racing, Johnson could of secured several more titles if it wasn’t for the exploits of McCoy.

With McCoy now no longer on the scene, it would be reasonable to suggest that Johnson has now picked up better rides.

However, while McCoy was known as the go-to man for any big occasion, that hasn’t really been the case for Johnson, who does not seem to pick up as many big rides, such as in the feature races at the Cheltenham Festival as the twenty-time Champion did.

Johnson’s winning rides have come in the lower graded day-to-day meetings in recent years, which helps explain the fact that the overall quality of his rides has marginally decreased, thus giving McCoy the backing of the best in the business.

The average Timeform master rating of Johnson’s rides during the McCoy era stood at 114.8, but has dropped slightly to 113.8.

While the quality hasn’t improved, if Johnson continues on his current path, he would overhaul McCoy’s total record winners in the next five seasons. But would this mean he is the better jockey?

Referring back to the original debate, McCoy would still get the verdict, as not only he came out on top in the Championship for all those years, but also of the quality of the horses he won on.

Some of McCoy's victors would not have prevailed without the great man on board, who got the absolute maximum out of every runner - not that Johnson does not.

But these came in the biggest races, with undoubtedly one his best performances in the saddle, coming aboard Wichita Lineman in the 2009 William Hill Trophy:

The greatest of all time.

Free Bets & Offers


🔶 Bet £10 get £50 in free accas 🔶
Min stake £10, min odds 2.0. Only deposits made using Credit/Debit Cards or ApplePay will qualify. Free bets are awarded after the qualifying bet has settled, valid for 30 days, must be used on multiples with 3+ legs. Max £50 in free bets. T&Cs apply.
Claim Bonus
😍 Get up to £50 in Free Bets 😍
T&Cs: New users only. Min deposit £20. Place qualifying bets of £20 to £50 in first 7 days after deposit to unlock free bets. Free bet rewarded as 4 free bets that total the first deposit amount. Min odds 1/1 3+ legs & expire in 7 days. Winnings credited in cash. Full T&Cs apply
Claim Bonus
💥 BET £5 ON HORSE RACING & GET £30 IN FREE BETS! 💥
FIRST SINGLE & E/W BET ONLY. ODDS OF 1/1 OR GREATER. 3 X £10 BET TOKENS. FREE BET STAKES NOT INCLUDED IN RETURNS. FREE BETS ARE NON WITHDRAWABLE. NO FREE BET EXPIRY. ELIGIBILITY RESTRICTIONS. FURTHER T&CS APPLY. 18+. BEGAMBLEAWARE.ORG
Claim Bonus
📲 BET £10 GET £40 AT WILLIAM HILL 📲
New customers who register via mobile only, min £10/€10 stake, win only, min odds 1/2, free bets paid as 4x£10/€10 (30 day expiry), free bet/payment method, player/country restrictions apply
Claim Bonus
🏆 BET £20 & GET YOUR STAKE BACK AS CASH IF YOU LOSE! 🏆
New customers only. Minimum odds 1/5 (1.2). If you place a multiple at least one selection must meet the min odds requirement. Max £20 refund. Only deposits made using Cards or Applepay qualify. Qualifying bet must be placed and settled within 30 days of account opening. T&Cs apply.
Claim Bonus
🏆 £20 Risk Free First Bet - Money Back in CASH 🏆
New customers only, limited to one per person. If you’ve previously had a Paddy Power account, you will not qualify for the offer. Place your first bet on any Sportsbook market and if it loses we will refund your stake in CASH. Max refund for this offer is £/€20. Only deposits made using Cards or Paypal will qualify for this promotion. T&Cs apply.
Claim Bonus
100% Matched Free Bet up to £10!
New UK customers only. £10 Min Deposit. 100% matched free bet on your first deposit of £10. 1 x wagering at odds of 1.75+ to unlock Free Bets. Debit Card & Paypal deposits only. This offer is valid for 7 days from your new account being registered. Full Terms apply.
Claim Bonus
⚡️Get up to £100 in Bet Credits⚡️
New Customers only. Up to £100* in Bet Credits. Sign up, deposit £5* or more to your account and bet365 will match your qualifying deposit in Bet Credits when you place qualifying bets to the same value and they are settled. Min odds/bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. T&Cs, time limits & exclusions apply.
Claim Bonus
🌟 Bet £5 & Get £30 in Bonuses 🌟
New Customers only. Deposit and place a £5 qualifying bet at odds of 2.00 or greater within 7 days of opening a new account; excludes cashed out bets. Receive 2x £10 Sports/Virtual Sports Free Bets, valid on set events only at odds 2.00 or greater, expires in 7 days, plus a £10 Casino Bonus, expires in 7 days. Wager the Casino Bonus 35x to withdraw winnings. Payment Cards only. Geographical Restrictions and T&Cs Apply. Please Gamble Responsibly
Claim Bonus
When The Fun Stops. Stop.